Cafe Manhattan

Located in the heart of Clayton, MO, Cafe Manhattan is a charming American restaurant that perfectly captures the nostalgic spirit of a classic New York-style diner with a Midwestern twist. From the moment you step inside, the inviting atmosphere — brimming with retro NYC-inspired decor — transports you back in time, making it a beloved spot for locals and visitors alike who crave both comfort and culinary delight.

The menu is a treasure trove of all-American favorites, thoughtfully prepared and bursting with flavor. Whether you're indulging in their famously hand-breaded toasted ravioli or savoring the juicy, perfectly grilled Classic Burger, each bite is a satisfying experience. Their seasoned Beef Sandwich and Manhattan Club offer a hearty, well-seasoned punch, while the Buffalo Chicken Wrap provides a spicy kick that’s balanced by the fresh ingredients. If pizza is more your speed, the Margherita, Greek, and Pepperoni Pizzas stand out with their crisp crusts and vibrant toppings.

Sweet indulgences at Cafe Manhattan are nothing short of memorable. For dessert lovers, the Fitz's Rootbeer Float is a frosty, bubbly treat that complements the homemade Milkshakes — rich, creamy, and available in a variety of classic flavors. Don't miss the Banana Split, a perfect trip down memory lane. And for a unique touch, the Dozen or Half Dozen Donuts, freshly handpacked from Donut DriveIn, provide a delightful assortment of fresh, nut-free varieties that change daily, making every visit a little surprise.

Guests frequently applaud the warm and genuine service as much as the food. The friendly staff, exemplified by the welcoming personality of servers like Kathy, create a sense of community and belonging that's just as satisfying as the delicious fare. Reviewers highlight the genuine excitement and comfort the cafe radiates — from the old-school diner vibe to the efficient yet personable service, it’s clear that Cafe Manhattan doesn’t just serve food, but an experience.

While some mention that the seating shows its age, adding to the authentic diner aesthetic, it’s the quality and flavor of the food that leave a lasting impression. The menu’s carefully crafted sandwiches, soups, and snacks showcase refined homestyle cooking that’s both filling and flavorful — highlighted by favorites like the patty melt, potato soup, grilled cheese with tomato soup specials, and the ever-popular Mozzarella Sticks and Meatball Sub.

Whether you’re seeking a casual lunch, a nostalgic dinner, or just a comforting place to savor a coffee or cappuccino alongside scrumptious bites, Cafe Manhattan is a hidden gem worthy of discovery in Clayton. With its combination of inviting vibes, diverse menu offerings, and heartfelt service, it delivers a truly memorable dining experience that keeps guests coming back time and again.

Contact Information:
Address: 505 S Hanley Rd, Clayton, MO 63105, United States
Phone: +1 314-863-5695